NassirUDeen writes "When the servant is concerned about an affair or decides upon a matter, or a problem arises in his mind and he wishes to act upon it, then he should seek guidance from his Lord before embarking upon it (as established in Sahih Bukhari vol.2, no.263; Ahmad 3/344; Abu Dawood vol.1. no.1533, an-Nasa'i no.3253, Tirmidhi no.480, Ibn Majah no.1383) by the following:
FIRSTLY: that he fulfills all the
conditions of superogatory prayer - which are the same conditions for the
obligatory prayer except the condition of enterning of the time for that
particular prayer.
SECONDLY: that he prays two rakaahs of
superogatory prayer, with the intention of al-Istikharaah (seeking guidance).
THIRDLY: after the prayer, he
should make the supplication of al-Istikharaah: Transliteration: Allahuma inni
astakhiruka bi'i3lmika, wa astaqdiruka biqudratika, wa as'aluka min
fadhlika-l'a3zeem, fa innaka taqdiru wa la aqdiru, wa ta3lamu wa la a'a3lamu, wa
anta a3laamu-l'ghuyub Allahumma in kumta ta3lamu anna hatha-l'amr (and here he
mentions his need) khayru-lii fi diini wa ma3aashii wa a3aaqibati amrii
faaqdirhu lii wa yassirha lii thumma baarik lii fihi wa in kunta ta3lamu ana
hatha-l'amr (he mentions his need) sharru-lii fi diini wa a3aashii wa a3aaqibati
amrii faasrifha a3nii wa asrifni a3nhu wa-qdir lii al-khayra haythu kaana thumma
raddhinii bihi Translation: O Allah, I seek your counsel by Your
knowledge and I seek your assistance by Your power and I ask You from Your
immense favor, for verily You are able while I am not, and verily You know while
I do not, and You are the Knower of the Unseen. O Allah, if You know this affair
(and here he mentions his need) to be good for me in relation to my religion, my
life and aftermath, then decree it and facilitate it for me, and bless me with
it, and if You know this affair to be ill for me concerning my religion, my life
and end, then remove me from it, and decree for me what is good, wherever it
maybe, and make me satisfied with it FOURTHLY: He should have a strong assurance
in his Lord and truthful reliance upon his Lord , being sure of guidance,
waiting for the answer.
DOES ANYTHING PREVENT THE
SUPPLICATION FROM BEING ANSWERED? Yes! al-Istikharaah is a du'aa (supplication)
so the Muslim should fulfill all the conditions of making a du'aa and avoid all
obstacles and barriers that prevent a dua from being answered. Such obstacles
are: (1) earnings of the individuals are haram e.g.. dealing with interest ,
illegally gained wealth, deception, as the Prophet saw mentioned the case of a
man who having journeyed far, disheveled and dusty and who spreads out his hands
to the sky (saying): O lord! O lord! - whilst his food is unlawful, his drink
unlawful , his clothing unlawful and he is nourished unlawfully.
So how can he be answered! (Muslim,
2/2214) (2) If the dua'a requests something which is sinful or involves
oppression Ubadah ibn as-Samit (ra) relates that the Messenger of Allah (saw)
said: There is not a Muslim on the face of the earth that invokes Allah with a
supplication except that he will be granted it or will be protected from an evil
equal to his supplication, so long as the supplication is not for a sinful
matter or for severing the family ties (Tirmidhi no.3568; see also Ahmad 3/18;
and al-Haakim 1/493) (3) Abandoning of enjoining the good and forbidding the
evil i.e. not advising fellow muslims. Hudayfah (ra) said the Messenger of Allah
(saw) said By Him in Whose hand is my soul - you must order the good and forbid
the evil, or soon will Allah send upon you a punishment from Him and then you
will supplicate to Him but your supplication will not be answered (Ahmad 5/338,
Tirmidhi no.2169) (4) Exceeding the limits in making du'aa such as raising one's
voice or committing an innovation in du'aa, making something a partner to Allah
in one's duaa.
The Prophet (saw) said There will be a
people who will exceed the limits in making du'aa (Ahmad 1-172-183, Abu Dawood,
Vol 1, 1475; see also Quran 7:55) (5) The supplicant being heedless of Allah,
turning away from his Deen, neglectful of His orders and falling into His
prohibitions. The Prophet (saw) said Call upon Allah whilst being sure of being
answered and know that Allah does not answer the supplication from one whose
heart is heedless, inattentive (al-Haakim, Tirmidhi (3381). (6) Contradicting
some of the Shariah rulings There are three types of people who call upon Allah
yet they will not be answered. A man married to a woman of evil character and he
does not divorce her, a man who lends another man some money but does not take
witnesses to it and a man who gives money to a foolish person (al-Haakim,
adh-Dhahabee, at-Tahaawee).
WHAT IS THE RULING ON AL-ISTIKHARAAH?
The hadith is in the imperative case which suggests it is obligatory but no
scholar has said this. (al-Iraqi, Sharh at-Tirmidhi 2/335) Kitab Hadith Salat
al-Istikharaah). The scholars are united on the fact it is recommended.
WHAT ARE THE AFFAIRS IN WHICH ONE MAKES
ISTIKHAARAH? Istikharaah is made in every affair which is mubaah (allowed) and
it can be in obligatory or recommended matters in which one has a choice (see
Ibn Hajr, Fath ul-Baree 11/184), as in the choice of time, place or in
specification, or when obligatory and superogatory actions conflict with one
another. This clarifies the statement of Jaabir ibn Abdulllah (ra): He used to
teach us al-istikharaah in all of our affairs. e.g.. seeking knowledge is
recommended and sometimes can be obligatory, so he makes al-istikhaarah
concerning the type of knowledge to seek, the time and the place in which he
studies, i.e. those matters where the servant has a choice. e.g.. hajj is
obligatory so he makes al-istikharaah concerning the people whom he makes hajj
with and the way to travel and when to depart. e.g.. the servant has a choice in
whom he/she marries therefore one makes istikharaah with regard to an
individual, not concerning getting married itself. al-Istikharaah can be made in
those affairs whose result is known because Allah alones knows the reality of
the results and their consequences. So whatever a servant may think from his own
opinion may not always be the correct opinion; how many times did a person
consider something to be good yet it resulted in his destruction? and how many
times did a person consider something to be evil yet it resulted in his success?
WHAT SHOULD ONE DO AFTER HE MAKES AL-ISTIKHARAAH?
He should firmly resolve to do that which he perceives to be correct, without
hesitation or sadness, without sluggishness or fear, after placing his trust
truly upon Allah. Then when you have taken a decision, put your trust in Allah
(3:159). He should be truthful in his intention, sincere in the actions in the
matter in which he has sough ghuidance. He does this, whether his heart is happy
or not about the affair, whether the happiness of his heart was before or after
making al-istikharaah, because the affair is not determined by the happiness of
the heart, rather it is determined by Allah granting and making the affair easy.
So perhaps his heart is happy for an affair but Allah does not intend it for
him, so He does not make it easy for him even though he may begin it. As for the
hadith of Anas (ra) then look towards what your heart follows for in it lies the
good, then it is very weak (not authentic).
THE IMPORTANCE OF DREAMS? The matter is
determined by Allah making the affair easy and Him granting it, not by the
expansion of one's chest, nor by a dream which a person sees anything. Let us
assume he had a dream; how does he know that the dream is from Allah and not
from shaytaan or from the talking of his soul? The Prophet (saw) said, Dreams
are of three types: glad tidings from Allah, whispering from the soul or
frightening thoughts from Shaytaan (at-Tirmidhi, IbnMajah)
REPEATING AL-ISTIKHARAAH MORE THAN ONCE
FOR A PARTICULAR MATTER? Superogatory actions are of various types; as for the
prayer that is for a need and is of a particular description, the majority of
people of knowledge allow it to be repeated. Imam Ash-Shaafi'i, Imam Ahmad and
Imam Malik were amongst those who allowed repeating the prayer for rain
(al-Mughni,2/95) and Salaatul Istikharaah resembles the prayer for rain for they
are both for a specific need and both are combined with a du'aa. Making du'aa
plentifully is something desired therefore we do not see anything wrong with
repeating al-istikharaah. Abdullah ibn az-Zubair (ra) in Sahih Muslim, vol.2,
3083, after the kabah caught fire - ...So how about the house of your Lord?
Verily I will pray al-istikharaah three times, and then make up my mind about
this affair. As for the hadith of Anas who said that the Messenger of Allah said
O Anas. If you are concerned about an affair, seek guidance (by praying al-istikharaah)
from your Lord, with regard to it, seven times (Ibn as-Sinee) - it is very weak.
An Nawawee said in Al-Adhkaar, its chain is ghareeb (a single narrator in one of
the levels of the chain of narration) and in it are those whom I do not know of.
Al-Iraqee said, in Nayl al-Awtaar, The hadith is saaqit (extremely weak), there
is no proof in it. Ibn Hajr al-Asqalaanee said in al-Fath (11/187) its chain is
waahin jiddan (extremely weak).
DOES IT HAVE A PARTICULAR OR FAVOURED
TIME? It does not have a particular time - it can be performed at any time,
though there is nor harm in performing it at the times which a du'aa is more
likely to be answered - (1) the time between the adhaan and the iqaamah: The dua
between the adhan and the iqaamah is not refused ( Ahmad; Abu Dawood, vl1. no
52, Tirmidhi and others) (2) During rainfall. Two duas are not refused: the dua
during the call for prayer and at the time of rainfall. (Bukhari, Muslim and
Ahmad) (3) During the last third of the night. Our Lord - the Blessed and Most
High - descends every night to the lowest heaven when only the last third of the
night remains and says; Who is calling upon Me so that I may answer him? Who is
asking Me so that I may give what he asks? Who is seeking Myforgiveness so that
I may forgive him? (Muslim vol 1. no1656) (4) the last hour of Friday. There is
an hour on friday that if a Muslim coincides with it, standing in Salah (du'aa)
and asking Allah for goodness, then he is surely granted what he asks for. The
majority of the scholars are of the opinion that it refers to the last hour
based on this hadith, Abu Dawud, Tirmidhi, search for it in the last hour after
asr (salah). (5). Whilst traveling. There is no doubt in three supplications
being answered: the supplication of the father against his son, the supplication
of the traveler and the supplication of the one who is oppressed (Ahmad, Abu
Dawud, vol.1 1531, at Tirmidhi)
CAN IT BE MADE AFTER A SUNNAH SALAH OR
A SALAAH PERFORMED DUE TO AN EXTERNAL REASON? It is allowed to perform the du'aa
after a sunnah salaah although it is better and more conducive to be acceptable
with an independent salaah. This is further away from differences of opinion.
an-Nawawi said: It is recommended to perform al-Istikharaah with an independent
salaah.. what is apparent is that it can be achieved by two rakahs of sunnah
salaah and by the salaah performed upon entering a masjid. Shaykh Adnan states
that one must make the intention of al-Istikharaah. Al-Iraqi said: And if he
made the intention of sunnah salah and also al-Istikharaah he may or may not
achieve them due to their combination. However it is not seen as permissible to
perform the dua after the prayer of rain or eclipse.
CAN IT BE MADE FOR TWO AFFAIRS
SIMULTANEOUSLY? If the two affairs are linked, then there is no doubt in its
permissibility, such as the issue of marrying a woman with the question of the
amount of mahr. In the case of the two affairs being disconnected, there is a
difference of opinion. Sheik Ibn Baize does not consider it objectionable
whereas Sheik al-Albanee disagreed.
CAN ONE MAKE THE DU'AA BY ITSELF
WITHOUT THE TWO RAKAHS OF SALAAH? If one is forced, due to time constrictions or
is unable to perform two rakahs then he can make the du'aa itself (an-Nawawi, Al
AlAdhkaar pg. 110-111). But it is most correct to perform it with the two rakahs
as one should always perform worship in the most complete manner, away from
doubts anddifferences.
IS IT PERMISSIBLE TO MAKE AL-ISTIKHARAAH
FOR SOMEBODY ELSE? This is a question which required ijtihaad. If one looks to
the hadith then it is apparent that it is not done for somebody else as the
affair is associated with the person it directly concerns, i.e. - if one of you
is concerned about an affair.... However if it is something which is shared then
the individuals concerned can make istikhaarah. For example like marrying one's
son or daughter or if it is an affair particular to someone who himself is not
responsible for his actions, such as performing an operation for a child. In
these instances it is allowed to make al-istikharaah for somebody else, since
the father would hold a great connected to the matter.
KNOWING WHETHER THE DU'AA IS ANSWERED
The du'aa of one of you in answered so long as he does not become impatient and
say I made a du'aa to my Lord but He did not answer me (Bukhari, vol.8 352;
Muslim, vol.4 6595). Only Allah knows the truly reality of an affair, therefore
if something seemingly bad is decreed then perhaps in reality, it is inwardly
good for the individual. Anas (ra) reported that the Prophet (saw) said: I am
astonished for the believer. Verily Allah, the Most High, does not decree
anything for him except that it is good for him (Ahmad).
SOME FURTHER POINTS * Salaat ul
Istikharaah is not allowed in the times when salah is prohibited *There is no
specific surah to be recited in al-Istikharaah. *The du'aa is to be performed
after the two rakahs, without interruption. If one forgets to say it immediately
but he still has wudhu and is still sitting then he should make it. If one has
walked away then he must repeat the two rakahs. * It is necessary to adhere to
the exact text - Verily the wordings of the duas are maintained exactly to the
form established from the Prophet (an-Nawawi, al-Majmoo 3/495). The scholars
differ whether one is permitted to say something before the dua (praising Allah
swt) and after it (saying salaam on the Prophet saw), as the general evidences
for du'aa suggest this; or if it should be disallowed given al-istikharaah is a
specific du'aa, therefore it is not befitting to add to it. *The general rule is
one hands should be raised unless proved that the Prophet (saw) did not do this
in a particular dua. Verily your Lord is generous, shy. If His servant raises
his hands to Him (in supplication) He becomes shy to return them empty (Ahmad,
Abu Dawood vol.1 1483, Tirmidhi) * Whether ones heart inclines towards something
before al-Istikharah or not, the individual should still make al-Istikharaah for
this affair. *The individual should also seek guidance from those whom he knows
to be righteous, whether before or after performing al-Istikharaah.(Summary from
the Book, The Three Abandoned Prayers by Shaykh Adnaan Ali Uroor)
Al Bayaan Newsletter
http://www.geocities.com/albayaan
"